| 1 | Patrick PonceScorecardPatrick Ponce's scorecard | 2:06.25 | 2:09.13 | 2:06.45 2:14.69 2:06.25 — — |
| 2 | Gideon DalumScorecardGideon Dalum's scorecard | 2:07.01 | 2:10.80 | 2:11.13 2:07.01 2:14.27 — — |
| 3 | Ryan PilatScorecardRyan Pilat's scorecard | 2:14.81 | 2:19.90 | 2:26.13 2:18.75 2:14.81 — — |
| 4 | Jadon CastilloScorecardJadon Castillo's scorecard | 2:08.80 | 2:20.75 | 2:08.80 2:10.08 2:43.38 — — |
| 5 | William Henry Ruppert VScorecardWilliam Henry Ruppert V's scorecard | 2:24.61 | 2:30.02 | 2:24.61 2:29.43 2:36.01 — — |
| 6 | Shu Ogawa (小川柊)ScorecardShu Ogawa (小川柊)'s scorecard | 2:23.94 | 2:33.97 | 2:30.63 2:23.94 2:47.35 — — |
| 7 | Jose Ortiz Jr.ScorecardJose Ortiz Jr.'s scorecard | 2:36.25 | 2:43.66 | 2:49.57 2:45.15 2:36.25 — — |
| 8 | Casey NgoScorecardCasey Ngo's scorecard | 2:33.36 | 2:44.92 | 2:44.02 2:57.39 2:33.36 — — |
| 9 | John Wanger IIScorecardJohn Wanger II's scorecard | 2:38.56 | 2:48.93 | 3:02.17 2:46.07 2:38.56 — — |
| 10 | Eli MaslowskiScorecardEli Maslowski's scorecard | 3:10.03 | 3:15.53 | 3:10.03 3:22.03 3:14.52 — — |
| 11 | Jonathan PelserScorecardJonathan Pelser's scorecard | 3:23.80 | 3:27.07 | 3:26.26 3:23.80 3:31.14 — — |
| 12 | Gavin UrquidezScorecardGavin Urquidez's scorecard | 3:17.26 | 3:30.11 | 3:29.98 3:43.09 3:17.26 — — |
Advancement cutoff · top 12 to Final |
| 13 | Jaxon SensabaughScorecardJaxon Sensabaugh's scorecard | 3:42.52 | 3:46.22 | 3:42.52 3:50.75 3:45.40 — — |
| 14 | Gavin DeVineScorecardGavin DeVine's scorecard | 3:34.15 | 3:57.91 | 4:06.23 4:13.36 3:34.15 — — |
| 15 | Noah SilvaScorecardNoah Silva's scorecard | 3:42.11 | 4:03.48 | 3:42.11 4:19.91 4:08.41 — — |
| 16 | Tyler GeeScorecardTyler Gee's scorecard | 4:07.07 | 4:27.00 | 4:26.35 4:07.07 4:47.59 — — |
| 17 | Christopher LongsworthScorecardChristopher Longsworth's scorecard | 4:18.69 | 4:34.71 | 4:18.69 4:48.23 4:37.21 — — |
| 18 | Alexander PachecoScorecardAlexander Pacheco's scorecard | 4:02.01 | 4:49.57 | 4:22.29 4:02.01 6:04.40 — — |
| 19 | Tim KwartlerScorecardTim Kwartler's scorecard | 4:39.22 | 4:52.96 | 4:57.45 4:39.22 5:02.22 — — |
| 20 | Lucas WoodScorecardLucas Wood's scorecard | 4:51.62 | 4:57.90 | 5:03.11 4:58.97 4:51.62 — — |
| 21 | Dylan MillerScorecardDylan Miller's scorecard | 5:20.29 | 6:14.66 | 5:20.29 6:59.78 6:23.91 — — |
| 22 | Zhea SalazarScorecardZhea Salazar's scorecard | 5:22.74 | DNF | 5:22.74 5:34.28 DNF — — |
| 23 | Ignacio MontillaScorecardIgnacio Montilla's scorecard | 6:08.55 | — | 6:08.55 — — — — |
| 24 | Abhinav AgarwalScorecardAbhinav Agarwal's scorecard | 6:15.41 | — | 6:15.41 — — — — |
| 25 | Nolan VarelaScorecardNolan Varela's scorecard | 6:17.94 | — | 6:17.94 — — — — |
| 26 | Caleb TorresScorecardCaleb Torres's scorecard | 7:06.43 | — | 7:06.43 — — — — |
| 27 | Michael ConardScorecardMichael Conard's scorecard | 7:08.13 | — | 7:08.13 — — — — |
| 28 | Sourish DattaScorecardSourish Datta's scorecard | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 28 | Landon LawrenceScorecardLandon Lawrence's scorecard | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |