| 1 | Henry Lichner | 1:47.14 | 1:51.76 | 1:50.00 1:47.14 1:58.14 — — |
| 2 | Ethan Cho | 2:06.32 | 2:09.86 | 2:15.45 2:06.32 2:07.81 — — |
| 3 | Max Walaszek | 2:12.70 | 2:20.14 | 2:12.70 2:25.81 2:21.92 — — |
| 4 | Lucas Lippman-Bruno | 2:27.11 | 2:29.76 | 2:27.11 2:34.22 2:27.94 — — |
| 5 | Brian Johnson | 2:34.97 | 2:39.70 | 2:45.06 2:34.97 2:39.07 — — |
| 6 | Carter Kucala | 2:38.78 | 2:41.82 | 2:38.87 2:38.78 2:47.82 — — |
| 7 | Sebastian Carrillo | 2:35.29 | 2:44.22 | 2:50.93 2:46.44 2:35.29 — — |
| 8 | Simon Kellum | 3:19.76 | 3:21.72 | 3:24.45 3:19.76 3:20.96 — — |
| 9 | Joshua Feran | 3:30.73 | 3:36.83 | 3:30.73 3:42.46 3:37.29 — — |
| 10 | Simon Poldi | 4:01.44 | 4:05.13 | 4:01.44 4:06.50 4:07.46 — — |
| 11 | Zachary Cribb | 4:07.62 | 4:25.37 | 4:48.06 4:07.62 4:20.44 — — |
| 12 | Mason Zimbelman | 3:55.49 | 4:29.55 | 4:44.42 3:55.49 4:48.75 — — |
| 13 | Kavindu Wimalaratne | 4:45.48 | 4:55.20 | 4:51.26 5:08.85 4:45.48 — — |
| 14 | Noah A. Wilson | 4:39.07 | 4:55.83 | 5:13.65 4:54.78 4:39.07 — — |
| 15 | Jameson R. Sramek | 4:48.51 | 4:58.12 | 4:54.37 5:11.47 4:48.51 — — |
| 16 | Ishmael Schimian | 4:37.29 | 5:12.34 | 4:37.29 5:20.53 5:39.19 — — |
| 17 | Jackson Smith | 7:17.12 | — | 7:17.12 — — — — |