| 1 | Paul Mahvi | 1:33.41 | 1:37.46 | 1:40.95 1:33.41 1:38.01 — — |
| 2 | Nicolas Naing | 1:39.38 | 1:42.28 | 1:47.12 1:39.38 1:40.34 — — |
| 3 | Timothy Castle | 1:43.32 | 1:52.73 | 1:55.73 1:43.32 1:59.14 — — |
| 4 | Ryan Pilat | 2:09.64 | 2:10.19 | 2:10.20 2:10.72 2:09.64 — — |
| 5 | Travis Burkett | 2:08.12 | 2:13.86 | 2:13.65 2:08.12 2:19.81 — — |
| 6 | Benjamin Gottschalk | 2:11.86 | 2:16.28 | 2:11.86 2:18.43 2:18.56 — — |
| 7 | Shane Grogan | 2:18.07 | 2:25.36 | 2:34.66 2:18.07 2:23.36 — — |
| 8 | Cade Beck | 2:22.47 | 2:37.85 | 2:30.06 2:22.47 3:01.03 — — |
| 9 | Antonio Bonessi | 2:50.67 | 3:04.28 | 3:16.30 3:05.87 2:50.67 — — |
| 10 | Isaac Myers | 2:57.98 | 3:05.99 | 2:57.98 2:58.82 3:21.17 — — |
| 11 | Canyon Pettitt | 3:13.57 | 3:27.71 | 3:13.57 3:50.49 3:19.07 — — |
| 12 | Keenan Pewitt | 3:45.19 | 4:17.25 | 3:45.19 4:00.24 5:06.32 — — |
| 13 | Max Fairbanks | 3:36.53 | 4:29.10 | 3:57.19 5:53.58 3:36.53 — — |
| 14 | Calvin Nielson | 3:48.03 | DNF | 3:48.03 DNF DNF — — |
| 15 | David Reid | 4:01.43 | — | 4:01.43 — — — — |
| 16 | Jacob Whitlock | 4:01.59 | — | 4:01.59 — — — — |
| 17 | Damian Wilding | 4:05.56 | — | 4:05.56 — — — — |
| 18 | Orion Leavitt-Lytle | 4:51.04 | — | 4:51.04 — — — — |
| 19 | Ethan R. Ashby | 5:35.38 | — | 5:35.38 — — — — |
| 20 | Jacob Goddard | 6:04.76 | — | 6:04.76 — — — — |
| 21 | Branson Costin | 6:08.56 | — | 6:08.56 — — — — |
| 22 | Eliot Torson | 6:14.84 | — | 6:14.84 — — — — |
| 23 | Luke Bailey | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |