| 1 | Lydia Workman | 1:57.90 | 1:59.11 | 2:01.40 1:58.03 1:57.90 — — |
| 2 | Zachary Walden | 1:54.24 | 2:00.17 | 1:54.64 2:11.63 1:54.24 — — |
| 3 | Daniel Mullen | 2:01.62 | 2:09.40 | 2:19.73 2:06.85 2:01.62 — — |
| 4 | Justus Danielsen | 2:22.41 | 2:26.41 | 2:24.59 2:22.41 2:32.23 — — |
| 5 | Titus Sutterfield | 2:26.46 | 2:38.29 | 2:26.46 2:48.03 2:40.39 — — |
| 6 | Edward Vakula | 2:29.29 | 2:41.50 | 2:43.47 2:29.29 2:51.74 — — |
| 7 | Katie Hinkley | 2:41.01 | 2:46.36 | 2:44.46 2:53.61 2:41.01 — — |
| 8 | Bryan Lindsley | 2:46.40 | 2:56.49 | 2:52.63 2:46.40 3:10.44 — — |
| 9 | Zachary Johnson | 3:06.64 | 3:14.87 | 3:06.64 3:24.70 3:13.27 — — |
| 10 | Andrew Thiesfeld | 3:04.81 | 3:18.99 | 3:21.31 3:04.81 3:30.85 — — |
| 11 | Isaac Lindsey | 3:26.46 | 3:45.97 | 3:58.10 3:26.46 3:53.36 — — |
| 12 | Lucas Stambaugh | 3:49.08 | 3:59.11 | 4:04.84 4:03.41 3:49.08 — — |
| 13 | Joseph W. Passer | 3:43.35 | 4:00.66 | 4:24.19 3:54.45 3:43.35 — — |
| 14 | Carter Rochleau | 3:48.16 | 4:12.57 | 4:01.01 3:48.16 4:48.55 — — |
| 15 | Jordan Russell | 4:04.56 | 4:33.90 | 4:50.34 4:46.79 4:04.56 — — |
| 16 | Katrina Wagner | 4:06.56 | 4:34.57 | 4:55.94 4:41.22 4:06.56 — — |
| 17 | Brendan Simoens | 4:08.32 | 4:35.90 | 4:38.45 5:00.94 4:08.32 — — |
| 18 | Shawn Leonhardt | 4:28.15 | 4:59.21 | 4:51.98 5:37.49 4:28.15 — — |
| 19 | Kevin Reyes-Velazquez | 3:04.85 | DNF | 3:04.85 DNF DNS — — |
| 20 | Dan Smith | 5:25.92 | — | 5:25.92 — — — — |
| 21 | Benjamin Theobald | 5:31.14 | — | 5:31.14 — — — — |
| 22 | Noah Tuttle | 5:47.77 | — | 5:47.77 — — — — |
| 23 | Gordon Thomas White III | 5:53.53 | — | 5:53.53 — — — — |
| 24 | Jason Green | 5:53.82 | — | 5:53.82 — — — — |
| 25 | Braxton Lee Fowler | 6:14.83 | — | 6:14.83 — — — — |
| 26 | Samuel Muchnick | 6:40.26 | — | 6:40.26 — — — — |
| 27 | Samuel Hitchcock | 7:52.66 | — | 7:52.66 — — — — |
| 28 | Kael Hitchcock | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 28 | Daniel Muchnick | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 28 | Jordan Kilmer | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |