| 1 | Dylan Miller | 1:04.74 | 1:08.33 | 1:06.21 1:04.74 1:05.55 1:16.44 1:13.22 |
| 2 | James Hildreth | 1:05.27 | 1:08.48 | 1:05.27 1:09.02 1:09.88 1:08.51 1:07.91 |
| 3 | Katie Hull | 1:06.71 | 1:09.53 | 1:25.07 1:12.72 1:07.43 1:08.43 1:06.71 |
| 4 | Micah Morrison | 1:06.47 | 1:20.05 | 1:30.91 1:29.63 1:06.47 1:23.76 1:06.77 |
| 5 | David Ludwig | 1:15.90 | 1:21.31 | 1:44.85 1:25.45 1:20.20 1:18.27 1:15.90 |
| 6 | Jacob Ambrose | 1:11.43 | 1:23.65 | 1:11.43 1:29.00 1:23.47 1:20.95 1:26.54 |
| 7 | Hunter Jones | 1:32.78 | 1:39.82 | 1:32.78 1:42.88 1:39.22 1:37.78 1:42.46 |
| 8 | Colin Crosskno | 1:35.19 | 1:45.17 | 1:35.19 1:35.64 1:42.00 1:57.87 1:58.15 |
| 9 | Caleb Wanca | 1:32.99 | 1:47.47 | 1:49.57 1:41.26 1:55.04 1:51.57 1:32.99 |
| 10 | Adam Moore | 1:41.53 | 1:47.86 | 1:42.90 1:55.61 1:41.53 1:57.23 1:45.06 |
| 11 | Zachary Garber | 1:41.78 | 1:50.19 | 1:41.78 1:53.54 1:47.18 1:49.85 1:54.56 |
| 12 | Alex Agranov | 1:49.56 | 1:56.43 | 1:49.56 1:58.84 1:56.06 2:09.85 1:54.39 |
| 13 | Colin Nelson | 1:58.59 | 2:05.27 | 2:03.79 1:58.59 2:03.23 2:13.58 2:08.79 |
| 14 | Gregary Kimbrell | 2:03.11 | 2:07.16 | 2:09.54 2:15.64 2:06.17 2:03.11 2:05.78 |
| 15 | Amos Johnson | 2:18.33 | 2:31.78 | 2:25.47 2:32.07 2:37.81 2:18.33 2:39.51 |
| 16 | Jordan Steen | 2:24.07 | 2:40.39 | DNF 2:49.35 2:33.46 2:38.37 2:24.07 |
| 17 | Patrick French | 2:41.70 | 2:55.17 | 2:45.88 2:50.29 3:34.09 2:41.70 3:09.34 |
| 18 | Nathan Campbell | 2:41.02 | 2:55.52 | 2:58.45 2:44.23 3:33.59 2:41.02 3:03.88 |
| 19 | Owen Morrison | 2:18.52 | 3:02.07 | 2:18.52 3:20.64 2:58.07 DNF 2:47.51 |
| 20 | Marcus Daniel Shirk | 2:49.18 | 3:11.84 | 2:49.18 3:16.28 3:00.04 3:30.11 3:19.20 |
| 21 | Walter Spickler | 3:17.66 | — | 3:17.66 DNF — — — |
| 22 | Joshua Townsend | 3:45.72 | — | 3:45.72 4:02.92 — — — |
| 23 | Yusef Ibrahim | 6:01.18 | — | 6:01.18 DNF — — — |