| 1 | Jeffrey Li | 1:59.86 | 2:06.20 | 2:08.29 2:10.44 1:59.86 — — |
| 2 | Cameron Soulagnet | 2:18.98 | 2:20.73 | 2:19.05 2:24.15 2:18.98 — — |
| 3 | Evan Liu | 2:36.36 | 2:38.74 | 2:42.47 2:36.36 2:37.40 — — |
| 4 | Jonah Crosby | 2:53.88 | 3:12.72 | 2:53.88 3:35.22 3:09.07 — — |
| 5 | Graeme Stone | 3:07.17 | 3:19.88 | 3:26.40 3:26.07 3:07.17 — — |
| 6 | Viktor Pearl | 3:16.85 | 3:27.32 | 3:16.85 3:39.82 3:25.29 — — |
| 7 | James Donahue | 4:12.81 | 4:17.75 | 4:12.81 4:20.56 4:19.88 — — |
| 8 | Thaddeus Ciras | 4:25.85 | 4:29.45 | 4:25.85 4:34.01 4:28.48 — — |
| 9 | Elijah Rain Phelps | 4:15.58 | 4:38.62 | 4:15.58 4:56.30 4:43.97 — — |
| 10 | Daniel Winterberg | 4:46.55 | 4:50.64 | 4:49.11 4:46.55 4:56.27 — — |
| 11 | Tim Reynolds | 4:33.96 | 4:54.84 | 4:33.96 5:17.69 4:52.87 — — |
| 12 | Teddy Hsu | 4:41.22 | 4:58.42 | 4:41.22 4:42.05 5:31.98 — — |
| 13 | Alex Cohen | 3:55.69 | DNF | 4:44.38 3:55.69 DNF — — |
| 14 | Tommy Szeliga | 4:15.13 | DNF | 4:47.17 4:15.13 DNF — — |
| 15 | Tess Weinstock | 6:21.02 | — | 6:21.02 — — — — |
| 16 | Jesse Mailloux | 7:14.13 | — | 7:14.13 — — — — |
| 17 | Rohan Volety | 8:25.84 | — | 8:25.84 — — — — |