| 1 | Kevin Hays | 1:57.43 | 2:08.92 | 2:08.38 2:20.94 1:57.43 — — |
| 2 | Aryan Kejriwal | 2:07.52 | 2:32.74 | 3:03.06 2:27.65 2:07.52 — — |
| 3 | Cameron Soulagnet | 2:36.51 | 2:39.74 | 2:39.84 2:42.86 2:36.51 — — |
| 4 | Marcus S. Bilik | 2:50.20 | 3:04.82 | 3:15.83 2:50.20 3:08.42 — — |
| 5 | James Quinn | 2:54.68 | 3:05.48 | 2:54.68 3:20.91 3:00.85 — — |
| 6 | Connor Reid | 3:23.69 | 3:26.78 | 3:23.69 3:30.31 3:26.35 — — |
| 7 | Zayn Khanani | 3:17.70 | 3:26.96 | 3:31.36 3:31.82 3:17.70 — — |
| 8 | Andrej Mikulić | 3:15.32 | 3:30.69 | 3:24.45 3:52.29 3:15.32 — — |
| 9 | Hassan Khanani | 3:25.57 | 3:32.87 | 3:25.57 3:35.71 3:37.34 — — |
| 10 | Will Russo | 3:23.44 | 3:33.64 | 3:33.98 3:23.44 3:43.49 — — |
| 11 | Thiago Han | 3:37.60 | 3:46.35 | 3:49.24 3:37.60 3:52.22 — — |
| 12 | Eben Quenneville | 3:41.84 | 3:52.11 | 3:59.16 3:41.84 3:55.34 — — |
| 13 | Carter Williams | 3:33.81 | 3:56.12 | 4:20.83 3:33.81 3:53.72 — — |
| 14 | Viktor Pearl | 4:00.14 | 4:09.32 | 4:05.51 4:00.14 4:22.32 — — |
| 15 | Rowe Hessler | 4:02.90 | 4:10.90 | 4:02.90 4:23.02 4:06.78 — — |
| 16 | James Donahue | 4:06.92 | 4:14.06 | 4:13.97 4:06.92 4:21.28 — — |
| 17 | Alex Cheng | 4:04.65 | 4:16.02 | 4:27.50 4:15.90 4:04.65 — — |
| 18 | Tommy Szeliga | 3:59.84 | 4:19.51 | 3:59.84 4:25.32 4:33.38 — — |
| 19 | Daniel Gutierrez | 4:08.24 | 4:30.57 | 4:31.30 4:08.24 4:52.17 — — |
| 20 | Aaron Fulling | 4:11.65 | 4:32.57 | 4:11.65 4:33.12 4:52.95 — — |
| 21 | Thaddeus Ciras | 4:23.59 | 4:37.29 | 4:23.59 4:47.74 4:40.55 — — |
| 22 | Aryeh Honig | 5:20.43 | — | 5:20.43 — — — — |
| 23 | Ryan Durette | 5:38.53 | — | 5:38.53 — — — — |
| 24 | Zachary Miller | 6:13.64 | — | 6:13.64 — — — — |
| 25 | Sam Cooperman | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Gabriel Wilson | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Eli Rogers | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Tim Reynolds | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |