| 1 | Ethan Cho | 2:25.44 | 2:32.23 | 2:36.88 2:34.38 2:25.44 — — |
| 2 | Tyler Johnson | 2:39.74 | 2:42.84 | 2:40.68 2:48.10 2:39.74 — — |
| 3 | Walker Welch | 2:39.14 | 2:48.81 | 2:40.03 2:39.14 3:07.25 — — |
| 4 | Kaius Young | 3:08.88 | 3:18.42 | 3:10.32 3:08.88 3:36.07 — — |
| 5 | Brody Meschke | 3:37.30 | 3:50.09 | 3:37.30 3:52.87 4:00.09 — — |
| 6 | James Ekins | 3:44.79 | 4:13.91 | 3:44.79 4:25.50 4:31.45 — — |
| 7 | Faiz Wareh | 4:24.07 | 4:33.09 | 4:47.41 4:24.07 4:27.80 — — |
| 8 | Wesley A. Johnson | 5:05.94 | 5:21.92 | 5:28.65 5:05.94 5:31.17 — — |
| 9 | Kyle Tierney | 5:06.90 | 5:23.02 | 5:06.90 5:49.06 5:13.09 — — |
| 10 | Jagger Thomas Klecatsky | 5:29.17 | 5:45.93 | 5:29.17 5:40.93 6:07.69 — — |
| 11 | Ben Christman | 5:39.30 | — | 5:39.30 — — — — |
| 12 | Jacob Whitlock | 5:58.04 | — | 5:58.04 — — — — |
| 13 | Jared Sikes | 6:40.67 | — | 6:40.67 — — — — |
| 14 | Luke Baker | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 14 | Ezekiel Jennings | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |