| 1 | James Hildreth | 2:00.74 | 2:06.69 | 2:12.45 2:06.88 2:00.74 — — |
| 2 | Phillip Lewicki | 2:05.41 | 2:14.81 | 2:17.59 2:05.41 2:21.43 — — |
| 3 | Rami Sbahi | 2:16.87 | 2:20.30 | 2:16.87 2:25.17 2:18.87 — — |
| 4 | Blake Thompson | 2:11.83 | 2:22.33 | 2:34.48 2:11.83 2:20.67 — — |
| 5 | Allen Gustrowsky | 2:23.74 | 2:31.27 | 2:25.81 2:23.74 2:44.25 — — |
| 6 | Nathan Dwyer | 2:23.64 | 2:31.87 | 2:47.56 2:23.64 2:24.40 — — |
| 7 | John Eppley | 2:35.55 | 2:47.24 | 3:03.42 2:42.75 2:35.55 — — |
| 8 | Andrew Reich | 2:43.72 | 2:49.45 | 2:46.54 2:58.08 2:43.72 — — |
| 9 | Benjamin Williams | 2:49.54 | 2:50.98 | 2:50.49 2:52.92 2:49.54 — — |
| 10 | Yuxuan Chen | 3:09.12 | 3:22.73 | 3:30.12 3:09.12 3:28.94 — — |
| 11 | Jack Manzo | 3:06.64 | 3:30.34 | 3:15.91 4:08.47 3:06.64 — — |
| 12 | Benjamin Pugh | 3:32.33 | 3:41.01 | 3:39.27 3:51.42 3:32.33 — — |
| 13 | Rob Duquette | 3:32.97 | 3:43.69 | 3:32.97 3:55.40 3:42.69 — — |
| 14 | Keith Kozma | 3:32.40 | 3:52.34 | 3:55.93 4:08.68 3:32.40 — — |
| 15 | Timothy Townley | 4:00.86 | — | 4:00.86 — — — — |
| 16 | Ben Zoller | 4:38.86 | — | 4:38.86 — — — — |
| 17 | Ian Drake | 5:05.76 | — | 5:05.76 — — — — |
| 18 | Jack Wagar | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |