| 1 | Zeke Mackay | 1:42.30 | 1:44.81 | 1:43.83 1:48.29 1:42.30 — — |
| 2 | Brian Johnson | 1:41.14 | 1:47.35 | 1:48.98 1:41.14 1:51.92 — — |
| 3 | Chaeli Baker | 1:42.70 | 1:49.25 | 1:50.54 1:54.50 1:42.70 — — |
| 4 | Sebastian Carrillo | 1:41.95 | 1:50.55 | 1:53.12 1:41.95 1:56.57 — — |
| 5 | Zachary Johnson | 1:50.08 | 1:59.36 | 1:50.08 1:59.81 2:08.18 — — |
| 6 | Benjamin J. Dunn | 1:47.95 | 2:02.24 | 2:15.81 2:02.95 1:47.95 — — |
| 7 | Alexander Gager | 2:03.01 | 2:04.32 | 2:03.01 2:06.12 2:03.82 — — |
| 8 | Simon Kellum | 2:03.64 | 2:11.45 | 2:08.97 2:03.64 2:21.75 — — |
| 9 | Braxton Lee Fowler | 1:59.84 | 2:12.47 | 2:23.11 1:59.84 2:14.45 — — |
| 10 | Liam O'Leary | 2:10.27 | 2:16.23 | 2:23.32 2:15.10 2:10.27 — — |
| 11 | Josiah Bell | 2:22.64 | 2:31.47 | 2:38.01 2:33.77 2:22.64 — — |
| 12 | David Woner | 2:24.33 | 2:32.49 | 2:32.10 2:41.04 2:24.33 — — |
| 13 | Alexander Wheeler | 2:33.83 | 2:36.55 | 2:40.20 2:35.61 2:33.83 — — |
| 14 | Trenton Cuzick | 2:38.68 | 2:41.60 | 2:46.30 2:38.68 2:39.83 — — |
| 15 | Oscar Mercado | 2:36.81 | 2:44.67 | 2:41.50 2:55.69 2:36.81 — — |
| 16 | Charley Boor | 2:56.07 | 3:07.06 | 2:56.07 3:12.10 3:13.01 — — |
| 17 | Vinny Bruno | 3:09.90 | 3:15.43 | 3:24.14 3:12.25 3:09.90 — — |
| 18 | Landrum McNiell | 3:26.54 | 3:28.07 | 3:27.13 3:30.55 3:26.54 — — |
| 19 | Jackson Scott Hill | 3:48.69 | 3:57.94 | 3:48.69 3:56.18 4:08.94 — — |
| 20 | Caleb Shonkwiler | 3:44.84 | 4:06.95 | 3:57.56 3:44.84 4:38.46 — — |
| 21 | Aubrey Kudzia | 4:09.73 | 4:18.77 | 4:09.73 4:13.66 4:32.92 — — |
| 22 | Shawn Doyle | 4:51.66 | — | 4:51.66 — — — — |
| 23 | Archer Wagner | 5:30.63 | — | 5:30.63 — — — — |
| 24 | Mickey Doyle | 5:40.41 | — | 5:40.41 — — — — |
| 25 | Dan Smith | 5:46.94 | — | 5:46.94 — — — — |
| 26 | Blaise Peterie | 5:56.68 | — | 5:56.68 — — — — |