| 1 | Aryan Kejriwal | 2:22.59 | 2:30.99 | 2:36.87 2:22.59 2:33.51 — — |
| 2 | Samantha Raskind | 2:49.95 | 3:05.99 | 3:20.51 3:07.50 2:49.95 — — |
| 3 | James Hildreth | 3:01.32 | 3:08.47 | 3:01.32 3:15.56 3:08.53 — — |
| 4 | Jonah Crosby | 3:12.59 | 3:17.87 | 3:12.59 3:19.54 3:21.47 — — |
| 5 | Sam Schultz | 3:15.79 | 3:18.49 | 3:18.54 3:15.79 3:21.13 — — |
| 6 | Brandon Delacruz | 3:16.46 | 3:26.93 | 3:16.46 3:35.61 3:28.72 — — |
| 7 | Daniel Rose-Levine | 3:24.31 | 3:30.09 | 3:34.82 3:31.15 3:24.31 — — |
| 8 | Jeffrey Li | 3:23.03 | 3:30.84 | 3:28.59 3:23.03 3:40.90 — — |
| 9 | Connor Reid | 3:27.57 | 3:36.36 | 3:46.83 3:27.57 3:34.68 — — |
| 10 | Will Russo | 3:54.25 | 4:00.72 | 4:08.98 3:54.25 3:58.93 — — |
| 11 | Zach Goldman | 3:52.29 | 4:09.24 | 4:31.04 3:52.29 4:04.40 — — |
| 12 | James Quinn | 3:59.55 | 4:13.96 | 3:59.55 4:28.04 4:14.30 — — |
| 13 | Alex Cohen | 4:10.45 | 4:27.10 | 4:10.45 4:46.91 4:23.94 — — |
| 14 | Gus Lipkin | 4:34.89 | 5:08.73 | 5:50.83 5:00.47 4:34.89 — — |
| 15 | Tim Reynolds | 4:36.06 | 5:19.34 | 6:01.01 4:36.06 5:20.96 — — |
| 16 | Connor Breen | 5:39.38 | 6:14.17 | 6:26.40 6:36.72 5:39.38 — — |
| 17 | Jonas Rajagopal | 5:33.47 | 6:15.87 | 5:33.47 7:11.76 6:02.38 — — |
| 18 | Thaddeus Ciras | 6:49.28 | 6:57.60 | 6:49.28 7:02.32 7:01.20 — — |
| 19 | Kevin Wilson | 6:44.00 | 7:09.69 | 6:44.00 7:11.74 7:33.33 — — |
| 20 | Parth Garg | 7:00.03 | 7:27.90 | 7:26.94 7:56.72 7:00.03 — — |
| 21 | Kyle Olsen | 8:29.95 | — | 8:29.95 — — — — |
| 22 | Dov Geoghegan | 9:22.72 | — | 9:22.72 — — — — |