| 1 | Aryan Kejriwal | 1:46.33 | 1:48.46 | 1:48.27 1:46.33 1:50.77 — — |
| 2 | James Hildreth | 1:57.70 | 2:08.23 | 2:08.27 1:57.70 2:18.72 — — |
| 3 | Jonah Crosby | 2:09.05 | 2:11.46 | 2:15.11 2:10.22 2:09.05 — — |
| 4 | Daniel Rose-Levine | 2:10.59 | 2:12.25 | 2:12.83 2:13.34 2:10.59 — — |
| 5 | Kevin Costello III | 2:09.40 | 2:14.96 | 2:09.40 2:09.95 2:25.54 — — |
| 6 | Samantha Raskind | 2:05.52 | 2:17.22 | 2:40.03 2:06.10 2:05.52 — — |
| 7 | Sam Schultz | 2:13.02 | 2:20.30 | 2:23.20 2:24.67 2:13.02 — — |
| 8 | Jeffrey Li | 2:24.66 | 2:32.08 | 2:26.52 2:45.05 2:24.66 — — |
| 9 | Connor Reid | 2:28.57 | 2:36.97 | 2:42.18 2:28.57 2:40.17 — — |
| 10 | James Quinn | 2:39.10 | 2:45.33 | 2:48.02 2:48.87 2:39.10 — — |
| 11 | Alex Cohen | 2:49.22 | 2:52.45 | 2:51.45 2:49.22 2:56.68 — — |
| 12 | Zach Goldman | 2:57.52 | 2:58.61 | 2:58.42 2:59.90 2:57.52 — — |
| 13 | Will Russo | 2:44.39 | 3:00.02 | 3:13.76 2:44.39 3:01.90 — — |
| 14 | Gus Lipkin | 3:05.52 | 3:17.77 | 3:21.16 3:05.52 3:26.64 — — |
| 15 | Tim Reynolds | 3:09.97 | 3:20.44 | 3:13.54 3:09.97 3:37.81 — — |
| 16 | Anton Machkasov | 3:16.61 | 3:39.44 | 3:41.96 3:16.61 3:59.76 — — |
| 17 | Jack Ngo | 3:23.69 | 3:45.19 | 3:51.91 3:59.98 3:23.69 — — |
| 18 | Jonas Rajagopal | 3:34.50 | 3:52.83 | 4:06.38 3:57.62 3:34.50 — — |
| 19 | JP Bulman | 3:31.37 | 3:56.08 | 3:31.37 4:24.55 3:52.32 — — |
| 20 | Thaddeus Ciras | 4:01.70 | 4:37.26 | 5:02.52 4:47.56 4:01.70 — — |
| 21 | Francesca Magnarelli | 4:27.70 | 4:45.27 | 5:12.88 4:27.70 4:35.23 — — |
| 22 | Kyle Olsen | 5:03.38 | 5:16.63 | 5:03.38 5:09.79 5:36.72 — — |
| 23 | Daniel Gutierrez | 5:20.34 | DNF | 5:20.34 DNF 5:49.29 — — |
| 24 | Dov Geoghegan | 6:26.28 | — | 6:26.28 — — — — |
| 25 | Nicolas Zerbinopoulos | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Brandon Delacruz | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Connor Breen | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 25 | Kevin Wilson | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |