| 1 | Vishwa Sankar | 1:51.54 | 1:59.37 | 2:09.48 1:51.54 1:57.10 — — |
| 2 | Field Noble | 2:16.73 | 2:35.87 | 2:44.88 2:16.73 2:46.01 — — |
| 3 | Noah Swor | 2:27.75 | 2:40.17 | 2:52.27 2:27.75 2:40.50 — — |
| 4 | Jared Stinson | 2:39.25 | 2:44.16 | 2:43.34 2:39.25 2:49.88 — — |
| 5 | Zachary White | 2:45.61 | 2:52.06 | 2:59.47 2:45.61 2:51.11 — — |
| 6 | Eli Parker | 2:47.10 | 3:00.21 | 3:05.28 2:47.10 3:08.26 — — |
| 7 | Kyra Joiner | 3:01.05 | 3:04.13 | 3:07.59 3:03.74 3:01.05 — — |
| 8 | Eli Smith | 2:41.33 | 3:04.25 | 3:14.45 2:41.33 3:16.96 — — |
| 9 | Ethan McClain | 3:02.85 | 3:06.21 | 3:11.01 3:02.85 3:04.78 — — |
| 10 | Daniel Mullen | 3:00.35 | 3:08.98 | 3:10.57 3:00.35 3:16.01 — — |
| 11 | Abdel Issa (عبدالرحمن عيسى) | 2:46.98 | 3:10.75 | 3:21.19 2:46.98 3:24.09 — — |
| 12 | Raymond Goslow | 2:57.35 | 3:15.09 | 2:57.35 3:18.37 3:29.55 — — |
| 13 | Elliott Ashe | 3:16.53 | 3:24.77 | 3:26.90 3:30.89 3:16.53 — — |
| 14 | Andrew Lee | 3:19.61 | 3:29.23 | 3:30.61 3:19.61 3:37.46 — — |
| 15 | Reece Manders | 3:27.80 | 3:32.89 | 3:38.27 3:27.80 3:32.61 — — |
| 16 | Lincoln Kim | 3:25.86 | 3:34.79 | 3:29.62 3:25.86 3:48.88 — — |
| 17 | Roman Wofford | 3:34.51 | 3:41.38 | 3:35.76 3:53.87 3:34.51 — — |
| 18 | Ulysse Gallois | 3:43.64 | 3:48.23 | 3:45.86 3:55.18 3:43.64 — — |
| 19 | Quinn Anderson | 3:37.87 | 3:50.66 | 3:37.87 4:09.14 3:44.96 — — |
| 20 | Jacob Ambrose | 3:50.57 | 3:51.26 | 3:50.76 3:52.44 3:50.57 — — |
| 21 | Thomas Bryan | 3:39.97 | 3:57.30 | 4:26.87 3:39.97 3:45.05 — — |
| 22 | Justin Barker | 3:51.69 | 4:01.15 | 4:04.62 3:51.69 4:07.15 — — |
| 23 | Katie Hull | 3:10.33 | 4:02.32 | 3:13.51 5:43.12 3:10.33 — — |
| 24 | Daniel Porter | 3:58.16 | 4:13.45 | 4:19.91 4:22.27 3:58.16 — — |
| 25 | Jackson Lewis | 4:10.91 | 4:15.11 | 4:10.91 4:19.02 4:15.40 — — |
| 26 | Kellan Butler | 4:13.26 | 4:22.37 | 4:13.26 4:34.65 4:19.19 — — |
| 27 | Dylan Girouard | 4:14.63 | 4:24.80 | 4:19.42 4:14.63 4:40.34 — — |
| 28 | Orion Leavitt-Lytle | 4:26.82 | 4:34.57 | 4:26.82 4:40.51 4:36.39 — — |
| 29 | Declan Mangan-Lamb | 4:17.48 | 4:39.70 | 4:17.48 5:05.44 4:36.18 — — |
| 30 | Enoch Sanders | 4:04.98 | DNF | 4:16.84 4:04.98 DNF — — |
| 31 | Rue Clippinger | 4:33.24 | — | 4:33.24 — — — — |
| 32 | Clay Moore | 4:50.36 | — | 4:50.36 — — — — |
| 33 | Antonio Bonessi | 4:53.17 | — | 4:53.17 — — — — |
| 34 | Daniel York | 4:56.47 | — | 4:56.47 — — — — |
| 35 | Andreas Lambropoulos | 5:24.61 | — | 5:24.61 — — — — |
| 36 | Jude Fleming | 5:54.41 | — | 5:54.41 — — — — |
| 37 | Silas White | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |
| 37 | Fred Johnson | DNF | — | DNF — — — — |