| 1 | Walker Welch | 1:53.92 | 1:58.74 | 1:57.30 2:05.01 1:53.92 — — |
| 2 | Carter Kucala | 2:06.88 | 2:08.36 | 2:10.04 2:08.17 2:06.88 — — |
| 3 | Joshua Feran | 2:15.85 | 2:25.94 | 2:44.65 2:15.85 2:17.32 — — |
| 4 | Simon Kellum | 2:21.76 | 2:35.72 | 2:28.97 2:56.43 2:21.76 — — |
| 5 | Ant Irizarry | 2:41.88 | 2:54.39 | 2:41.88 2:53.24 3:08.05 — — |
| 6 | Ethan Bockenhauer | 2:48.08 | 3:00.60 | 2:48.08 3:09.45 3:04.26 — — |
| 7 | Will Cerne | 2:44.43 | 3:19.45 | 2:44.43 4:14.88 2:59.05 — — |
| 8 | David Golisch | 3:38.21 | 3:48.02 | 3:46.01 3:59.83 3:38.21 — — |
| 9 | Ashley Gray | 3:41.68 | 3:48.15 | 3:46.12 3:56.64 3:41.68 — — |
| 10 | Rachel Feran | 3:41.53 | 3:50.38 | 4:06.60 3:41.53 3:43.02 — — |
| 11 | Christopher Baird | 3:44.70 | 4:01.08 | 4:17.85 3:44.70 4:00.69 — — |
| 12 | Finn X. Gotcher | 4:06.41 | 4:09.09 | 4:14.31 4:06.56 4:06.41 — — |
| 13 | Michael Conard | 3:53.44 | 4:09.86 | 4:18.66 3:53.44 4:17.48 — — |
| 14 | Destin Shulfer | 4:08.70 | 4:14.94 | 4:14.28 4:08.70 4:21.84 — — |
| 15 | William Grooms | 4:54.01 | 5:35.37 | 4:54.01 5:29.86 6:22.25 — — |
| 16 | Trevor Schepanski | 5:53.76 | — | 5:53.76 — — — — |