| 1 | Henry Lichner | 2:14.42 | 2:16.70 | 2:14.42 2:15.14 2:20.55 — — |
| 2 | Nathan Phillips | 2:23.14 | 2:24.71 | 2:24.03 2:26.97 2:23.14 — — |
| 3 | Paul Mahvi | 2:30.30 | 2:33.99 | 2:31.62 2:30.30 2:40.05 — — |
| 4 | Carter Thomas | 2:31.95 | 2:38.18 | 2:31.95 2:46.03 2:36.57 — — |
| 5 | Max Walaszek | 2:34.53 | 2:50.27 | 2:58.42 2:34.53 2:57.87 — — |
| 6 | Carter Kucala | 2:44.32 | 2:54.10 | 2:44.32 2:57.14 3:00.85 — — |
| 7 | Lucas Lippman-Bruno | 2:58.82 | 3:03.65 | 3:02.36 2:58.82 3:09.78 — — |
| 8 | Brian Johnson | 2:58.05 | 3:05.35 | 3:05.35 2:58.05 3:12.66 — — |
| 9 | Zeke Mackay | 2:57.02 | 3:06.86 | 3:10.51 2:57.02 3:13.05 — — |
| 10 | Oliver Phillips | 3:17.65 | 3:24.53 | 3:21.82 3:34.11 3:17.65 — — |
| 11 | Joshua Feran | 3:32.93 | 3:38.05 | 3:34.92 3:46.29 3:32.93 — — |
| 12 | Sebastian Carrillo | 3:25.19 | 3:39.12 | 4:05.67 3:26.51 3:25.19 — — |
| 13 | Simon Kellum | 3:44.52 | 3:47.32 | 3:48.78 3:48.67 3:44.52 — — |
| 14 | Ant Irizarry | 3:56.39 | 4:07.36 | 3:56.39 4:25.53 4:00.15 — — |
| 15 | Varun Gudibanda | 4:30.06 | 4:50.96 | 4:58.42 4:30.06 5:04.41 — — |
| 16 | Ethan Glynn | 4:52.42 | 5:04.86 | 5:04.03 4:52.42 5:18.13 — — |
| 17 | Ashley Gray | 4:53.61 | 5:11.15 | 5:24.96 5:14.87 4:53.61 — — |
| 18 | Charles F. Roller | 4:29.52 | DNF | 4:29.52 DNF 4:31.48 — — |
| 19 | Jameson R. Sramek | 5:31.41 | — | 5:31.41 — — — — |
| 20 | Rachel Feran | 5:32.04 | — | 5:32.04 — — — — |
| 21 | Thomas Reinke | 6:09.48 | — | 6:09.48 — — — — |
| 22 | Colin Sharpe | 6:45.61 | — | 6:45.61 — — — — |